


I am an Americanist obsessed with rediscovering the weird, old (maybe classic) America, while attempting to define and understand current political, social, and academic issues of our post-modern slash 9/11 society.





The Naked and the Dead, is reminiscent (trying to not make one of those epic comparisons) of Tolstoy’s War and Peace. I know it is a heavy-handed comparison, but hear me out. One of Tolstoy’s major themes in War and Peace is the role of important and impressive men in history. Men like Napoleon, the Tsar or in Mailer’s case General Cummings. Both Tolstoy and Mailer describe these men as larger than life figures who make decisions that affects hundreds of lives without regrets. These Uber-Men are god-like to the simple solders. While giving orders upon learning of a Japanese offensive Cummings, one of the officers noticed that “the enlisted men looked to him (Cummings) almost in awe” in his ability to spew out orders. Cummings is described as having inhuman amount of concentration with quick and instinctively just decisions. He even states about himself, “if there is a God, Robert, he’s just like me.”
However, what makes Cummings more dynamic is Mailer’s use of Cummings as the voice/figure head of the military superstructure. Cummings rules by fear and anxiety. He creates fear of retaliation from his officers towards the enlisted men. To Cummings “the army functions best when you’re frightened of the man above you, and contemptuous of your subordinates.” What differs here between Tolstoy and Mailer is Tolstoy seems to admire these Uber-Men, while Mailer gives a more complete description where they are worthy admiration yet are incredibly shady.

popularity. He can wear that ridiculously awesome glove, because he is Michael Jackson, and nobody is going to tell him to change.